Reply to comment


Visitor wrote:

Neither Frodo, Harry Potter, nor Winnie the Pooh created or took away anything.

Indeed. And as far as we know, neither did Vishnu, Darth Vader, Yahweh, gremlins, Allah, Quetzlcoatl, or Anne of Green Gables. Which is fine; we certainly don't expect fictional characters to do things in the real world.

Visitor wrote:

One can make as many blind insertions as they please, although they do not necessarily pertain to what is important. 

True! One can even fill whole books of scripture with blind insertions (assertions?), yet not get to what's important.

Visitor wrote:

No, hypothetically no one can restore an amputated limb.

In reality, true. (According to religion, there are gods, beings, spells, etc. that can restore limbs – though somehow never in verifiable fashion.)

Visitor wrote:

However, love and grace can get you through the trials of losing a part of your body.

Exactly! Love and grace will help immensely. While supernatural beings are not yet shown to help at all.

Visitor wrote:

Harry Potter may have been a New York Times bestseller, but we know very well the author who wrote those books - books that were made to be fictitious.  The Bible was written with the intent of sharing something real to everyone.

Yes! Both books (or both collections of books, I should say) were written by real, live people, with the intent of sharing something - stories, beliefs, ideas. Not with the same emphasis on those components or with the same content, obviously, but the core is the same: People creating works of fiction. And in these two cases, with results that have touched many, many readers.

Visitor wrote:

There have been more copies found of the letters from the Bible than there have been of the findings of Plato or Socrates.

Sorry, I honestly don't catch the gist of that closing sentence. But I appreciate the input; thanks!

Reply

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Spread the Gospel

Share/Save

Spake the people